1. Entertainment
Send to a Friend via Email

Your suggestion is on its way!

An email with a link to:


was emailed to:

Thanks for sharing About.com with others!

You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.

The Book of Happenstance

by Ingrid Winterbach

About.com Rating 2 Star Rating


The Book of Happenstance by Ingrid Winterbach
© Open Letter
Open Letter, June 2011

Helena Verbloem, employed by the Museum of Natural History in Durban, South Africa, is a lexicographer working towards the preservation of the fading corners of the Afrikaans language. Assisting the scholar Theo Verway, they plod through a veritable dictionary of complexly rooted vocabulary, each brooding on the supposed mutation and evolution of current words and those forgotten.

Helena leads a simple life at the museum, but that life is derailed when her home is broken into and burglarized. Her apartment is trashed and her carpet vandalized, but most devastating is the missing spread of shells that she had collected throughout her life. Helena imbued this system of shells with not only memories past but with much of her current anxieties; in the absence of these shells, her life begins to unravel.

Ingrid Winterbach gambles much of The Book of Happenstance on her readers' ability to understand the greater connection between Helena and her shells. At first, the disappearance of these shells seems no different than a missing cat in a Haruki Murakami novel, but Winterbach consistently revisits these shells with the obsession of a conchologist. It's very easy to be left behind, and difficult to gauge whether Winterbach wants her characters or these shells to be the more believable, significant presence.
As the novel progresses, it becomes increasingly more difficult to attach meaning to any of the story's events. This is partially the point of The Book of Happenstance; without her shells, Helena loses the ability to differentiate between significance and coincidence. In the novel's opening, Theo Verway is found dead in his office. The novel then jumps back nine months (to the day Helena's house was robbed) to explore the events leading up to Verway's death. Could this denouement have anything to do with Helena's missing shells? Or the mysterious financial donor to their lexicography project? What about the intrusive calls Helena receives at night from a distant acquaintance?

Winterbach wants to light up all these nodes, to connect everything to everything. This notion is actually explicitly laid out in the novel, explained through Helena's friend Sof:

"She points to the horizon. Sky and sea are now one uninterrupted, brooding plane. The ship lies motionless in the distance. 'That's how I would like to write if I could,' [Sof] says, 'with little happening ostensibly but everything charged with meaning.'"
The "everything" of this sentiment is where Winterbach goes astray. She reaches too wide for significant but disparate themes, at once trying to unite crime, science, linguistics and eroticism with the same coincidental charge. She plunges far too deep into scientific and linguistic minutiae, resulting in the criminal and sexual side of the novel to fall flat.
Helena's pursuits in science and language ultimately further Winterbach's multi-connected agenda, but much of Winterbach's success is at the cost of her novel's flow and character development. In scenes with Theo Verwey, Winterbach practically rewrites their Afikaans dictionary into the novel:

"...fomfaai and fonkfaai - to set things out of kilter. Foerneer (obsolete) - to furnish, to provide, and foepa - finished (usage uncommon). Foeterasie - monkey business. Folterbeul - torturer..."

We're supposed to read these definitions and build connections, but just as with the other facets of the novel Winterbach provides very little impetus to make these links. Eventually, The Book of Happenstance becomes nothing more than a book of untapped diversions. It is a very simple book, yet one that possesses enough dusty corners in which to search for meaning should you so desire.
Disclosure: A review copy was provided by the publisher. For more information, please see our Ethics Policy.
  1. About.com
  2. Entertainment
  3. Contemporary Literature
  4. Literary and General Fiction
  5. The Book of Happenstance by Ingrid Winterbach - Book Review

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.